Exterior-Leak
Exterior Leak on 6” Main
weld-seam
Weld Seam Corrosion Leak

CASE STUDY:
Florida Regional Mall

WPNI: Wet Pipe Nitrogen Inerting

Wet pipe fire sprinkler systems in malls are especially susceptible to accelerated corrosion rates because systems are drained and refilled frequently for tenant modification projects. The process adds fresh oxygen with each drain and refill cycle. A large regional mall in Tampa, Florida was experiencing one leak per month on its wet pipe fire sprinkler systems. The ECS Wet Pipe Nitrogen Inerting (WPNI) process designed specifically to prevent oxygen corrosion in wet pipe systems was used to stop the leaks.

History and Background

  • Mall opened 2001 – 11 years old when work commenced
  • Large, two level, regional mall located in Southern Florida
  • 1.19 million sq.ft . of gross leasable space 
  • 36 wet pipe fire sprinkler systems protect the tenant and common mall areas – anchor stores are served by separate systems not included in this study
  •  Electric fire pump supplied by municipal water fed the overhead bulk supply loop feeding system risers located in service corridors around the perimeter of the building

Fire sprinkler piping materials:

 Black steel schedule 10 mains


 Black steel cross mains and branch lines a mix of schedule 10 and 40

Project Background

  • The mall was experiencing multiple leaks on a monthly basis
  • 36 wet systems were nitrogen inerted in December 2012
  • Pipe replacement limited to repair of existing leaks
  • Only one leak since nitrogen inerting the wet pipe zones

Corrosion related leak history:

  • Leaks occurring in wet pipe branch lines and mains on a monthly basis
  • Leaks occurred in tenant spaces and common mall areas
  • Merchandise damage risk due to fire sprinkler water leak

Preliminary Assessment Work

Based on the history of leaks occurring in the facility, Engineered Corrosion Soluons was contracted to identify the root cause of the corrosion and develop a corrosion control strategy to prevent future leaks. The conclusion was that trapped air in the high points of the mains and branch lines resulted in oxygen corrosion of the piping. Oxygen corrosion resulted in the formation of iron oxide deposits in the system piping, further accelerating the metal loss and resulng in addional leaks. The recommended method of preventing addional metal loss and leaks was to remove oxygen from the sprinkler system by using nitrogen gas to inert the piping.

Implementaon of ECS Wet Pipe Nitrogen Inerng (WPNI)
  • No significant pipe replacement was performed, exisng leaks were addressed
  • Installaon of ECS Protector Nitrogen Inerng Vents on each of the 36 wet pipe systems
  • Installaon of ECS Protector Nitrogen Injecon Ports on each of the 36 wet pipe risers
  • Performed WPNI on all of the fire sprinkler systems using the ECS nitrogen inerng protocol for wet pipe fire sprinkler systems
  • Maintained inert state during subsequent drains and refills of the systems following specific ECS protocols
3 Pressurized Cylinders Provide Nitrogen Gas

Results and Conclusions

In late December, 2012, the ECS nitrogen inerng equipment was installed on the 36 wet pipe zones protecng the common mall areas and tenant spaces. ECS was onsite with the mall facilies personnel and fire sprinkler contractor to deploy the nitrogen inerng procedures. To ensure that the proper inerng protocols were followed, the mall owner dictated that the primary fire sprinkler contractor must always be onsite for any drain downs of the system. Even if another contractor performed any work in the facility, the primary contractor was present to perform the draining and refilling protocols to maintain the nitrogen inerted state on the systems.

Since the inial inerng of the 36 wet pipe systems the mall has only experienced one leak. The fire sprinkler contractor referred to WPNI as the ‘miracle cure’ that has completely resolved the mall’s corrosion issues.

Get Your Project Started with ECS Today

Learn More